PDF Ebook Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, by Martin van Creveld
Do you know why you need to read this website and also what the connection to reading publication Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld In this modern-day period, there are many means to obtain the book and also they will certainly be much less complicated to do. Among them is by obtaining guide Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld by on-line as just what we tell in the link download. The e-book Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld can be a selection due to the fact that it is so proper to your necessity now. To obtain guide online is very simple by only downloading them. With this possibility, you can read the e-book wherever as well as whenever you are. When taking a train, awaiting listing, and also hesitating for somebody or various other, you could read this on the internet publication Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld as an excellent close friend once more.
Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, by Martin van Creveld
PDF Ebook Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, by Martin van Creveld
Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld. Reading makes you much better. Who states? Numerous sensible words say that by reading, your life will certainly be much better. Do you believe it? Yeah, confirm it. If you require guide Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld to read to verify the sensible words, you can visit this web page completely. This is the site that will offer all the books that most likely you require. Are the book's compilations that will make you feel interested to review? One of them right here is the Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld that we will certainly recommend.
When some people taking a look at you while checking out Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld, you might really feel so pleased. However, instead of other people feels you must instil in yourself that you are reading Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld not because of that factors. Reading this Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld will certainly offer you greater than people admire. It will certainly overview of know more than individuals staring at you. Even now, there are numerous resources to learning, reviewing a publication Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld still comes to be the front runner as a great method.
Why should be reading Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld Again, it will certainly depend on how you really feel and also think about it. It is definitely that of the perk to take when reading this Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld; you can take a lot more lessons directly. Even you have actually not undergone it in your life; you could get the experience by reviewing Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld And also currently, we will certainly present you with the online publication Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld in this web site.
What sort of publication Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld you will favor to? Currently, you will certainly not take the published publication. It is your time to obtain soft documents book Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld rather the published documents. You could appreciate this soft data Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld in at any time you anticipate. Even it remains in expected place as the various other do, you could review the book Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld in your device. Or if you desire a lot more, you can continue reading your computer or laptop computer to obtain full screen leading. Juts find it here by downloading the soft file Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, By Martin Van Creveld in link web page.
Israel is a tiny country. From tip to toe, it stretches 260 miles long but is only 60 miles at its widest point. Since the days of the British mandate, the question of "defensible borders" for the Jewish state has always been problematic. Yet considering the larger picture of what has happened in the Middle East over the last 25 years -- the peace treaties with Egypt and Jordan, the weakening of Syria as a result of the collapse of the USSR, the smashing of Iraq by the U.S -- Israel is, militarily speaking, stronger than ever before. The greatest remaining threats are terrorism and guerilla warfare; and those, this book argues, are best dealt with territorial concessions. This is a compact, incisive study that is certain to draw attention.
- Sales Rank: #1908491 in Books
- Published on: 2004-10-06
- Released on: 2004-09-09
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 8.60" h x .90" w x 5.68" l,
- Binding: Hardcover
- 224 pages
From Publishers Weekly
In this clear and original book, Creveld (Moshe Dayan, etc.) argues effectively for Israel's withdrawal from the occupied territories—unilaterally, if necessary—on the grounds that it will make Israel more secure. A history professor at Hebrew University in Jerusalem, he details the change in Israel's military thinking after its 1967 victory in the Six-Day War and claims it's time to change once again. Creveld proposes a "military revolution": more mobile forces and a more decentralized command system that will be more capable of countering terrorist threats. This should be accompanied by a withdrawal from the Palestinian territories, he contends, which are sapping Israel's military and moral superiority at levels that far outweigh their economic and ideological value. While he admits that an Israeli withdrawal will not completely rid the country of terrorism, he asserts that it will likely take away some of the motivation for suicide bombers. He also argues forcefully that the conventional threat to Israel from Arab states has passed and that the nuclear threat, post–Saddam Hussein, may be exaggerated. At a time when the debate is bogged down and Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon is stuck in a back-and-forth with his party over withdrawing from Gaza, Creveld's innovative ideas deserve a wide readership. Maps. Agent, Artellus Ltd., U.K.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Review
"A provocative, ruthlessly honest, and ultimately persuasive argument for reorienting basic Israeli defense policies. Advocating partition as the only viable solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, van Creveld believes that the future security of the Jewish state requires the pursuit of a distinctively Israeli variant of the Revolution in Military Affairs."
- Professor Andrew J. Bacevich, author of American Empire: The Realities and Consequences of U. S. Diplomacy
About the Author
Martin van Creveld was born in the Netherlands in 1946 and has lived in Israel from 1950. Having studied in Jerusalem and London, since 1971 he has been on the faculty of the History Department, the Hebrew University, Jerusalem. A specialist in military history and strategy, he is the author of 17 books, and has appeared regularly on CBS, CNN and the BBC.
Most helpful customer reviews
15 of 15 people found the following review helpful.
Can good fences make viable neighbors?
By C. W. Richards
Guerillas, so long as they do not lose, win. This observation by Henry Kissinger--quoted by van Creveld in the same chapter where he recommends the wall--forms the backbone of the book: How does a small country with no strategic depth succeed where Kissinger and the United States failed? For the United States, loss in Vietnam was traumatic but not fatal. For Israel, with its tiny population, religious and cultural distinctiveness from its Arab antagonists, and only the width of the Jordan rather than breadth of the Pacific Ocean to withdraw behind, any loss could represent a mortal threat. It is not a risk that Israel is willing to take.
Van Creveld proposes a solution brilliant in its simplicity and creativity. If Israel cannot win an "evolved form of insurgency," as Marine Colonel T. X. Hammes described what is often known as "fourth generation warfare," (or as van Creveld calls it, "non-trinitarian war") the solution is to convert the struggle back to something Israel can win. This approach may be contrasted with Israel's current strategy, which is to use conventional forces to try to win an unconventional war. Van Creveld is proposing to first convert the struggle to a conventional one, then win--or what is much more likely, deter--it.
Building on the framework he established in The Transformation of War, van Creveld goes to some lengths to explain why Israel is unlikely to prevail in its struggle with the Palestinians by using its military forces to suppress the Intifada. Although the arguments are complex, they all come back to an observation by Joe Galloway (the reporter who was with Hal Moore at Ia Drang) that when conventional troops kill a guerilla, they create two more to take his or her place. If you throw in the higher birth rate of the inhabitants of the West Bank and Gaza, you see that Israel is fast running up against the dismal laws of arithmetic.
If one rules out rounding up all remaining Arabs and marching them across the Jordan or into the Sinai--such ethnic cleansing possibly achievable in 1967 but mere right-wing fantasy today--the solution is two fold. First separate the warring parties. This means withdrawing virtually all the settlements from the West Bank and absolutely all of them from Gaza and building a wall "so high a bird can't fly over it." This produces two well-defined geographical entities with fairly short borders (much shorter than current Israeli plans for the security fence.) It would also remove the 120 or so settlements, which now require more force to protect than Israel used to defeat Egypt in the 1967 war. Then exploit Israel's universally recognized superiorities in maneuver warfare and advanced technology to deter or speedily interdict and defeat any attack, which would now have to be conventional, from any Arab state including the new Palestinian one. At some point in the future, when both parties desire it, the wall can be torn down. In the meantime, van Creveld predicts that a secure Israel will be able to redeploy its human and economic resources to resume the economic growth that was interrupted by the Palestinian uprisings.
There are at least two arguments against this approach, and van Creveld considers them both. Some have argued that it would amount to a reverse "ethnic cleansing" of Jews from the West Bank. This is a difficult argument for a non-Israeli to comprehend, since all the Jews on the West Bank moved there after the 1967 war to occupy land owned by Arabs. Many have already left. The other involves water. Van Creveld is, in my opinion, unduly optimistic on this point. Water from the West Bank's "Mountain Aquifer" and from the Jordan River (to which a Palestinian state would also have a claim) provides about a third of Israel's consumption. Foregoing this would significantly hamper agriculture (which currently uses more than half of all Israeli water resources) and, as he notes, would require building expensive and strategically vulnerable desalinization plants. It can be done, and it may have to be done, but it will require a major cultural shift from the notoriously profligate use of water by the Israelis.
For all who have been wondering what an end state in the Middle East might look like, that is, one that did not leave the place a radioactive desert even hotter than the one there now, van Creveld offers a message of hope. It will certainly not satisfy the fanatics on either side, but that is probably a good test of its justice if not its feasibility.
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful.
A Military analysis
By Seth J. Frantzman
of defensible borders. Israel has fought 5 major wars, each one to secure its borders. 1948 was to create a country. 1956 was to stop the infiltration and prempt Egypt's growing army. 1967 was fought out of desperation, but led to the creation of a `Greater Israel'. 1973 was a defensive conflict, that almost proved a disaster. 1982 was fought to stop the shelling of the Galilee by a proto-Palestinian state in Lebanon. The recent pseudo-conflicts of the First(1989-1992) and primarily the second Intifada(2000-present) have created new border issues, resulting in the construction of the security fence.
Creveld fresh from his studies of the IDF and Dayan now uses his analysis in this fresh and insightful book to explain the question of defensible borders and how they relate to Israel today. In 1948 any military tactician could see the borders `given' to Israel by the U.N and rejected by the Arab leadership, were indefensible. The Arab state controlled the high ground, Israel the coastal plain. Israel was roughly 9 miles wide, meaning the country could be cut in half in a days fighting. But today, as Creveld points out, Israel has the best military in the Middle East, and perhaps the best in the world. Israel's inventiveness have led to her developing of the Merkava tank and other weapons that could easily clean up the armies of her neighbors. Beyond Israel's army are the peace treaties that at least on paper guarantee Israeli security against a renewal of the 1967 situation, the situation that caused the conquest of the West Bank and Gaza. Today the threat is terror. And terror, unlike the Germans, can actually be stopped by maginot line style defenses, listening posts, and other technology based infrastructure. This book argues passionately, and intelligently that Israel's military solution should be a withdrawal to a line somewhere near the green line, that can be easily defended and yet leaves the majority of palistinians outside Israel, to fend for their own destiny. This book does not ask hard questions, such as what to do with the 250,000 Israelis living in villages on the West Bank, but it does give a military solution. An excellent, well thought out, non-emotional approach, this will be enjoyable reading for any student of the middle east conflict and anyone wanting to understand one path to peace.
Seth J. Frantzman
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful.
The Most Influential Book Governing Middle East Politics Today
By Jose C. Tejeda Jr.
Defending Israel is an excellent book written by the world-renowned military historian, Martin Van Creveld. This book can best be described as an essay on how Israel can best protect its borders now and in the future. In it, he asserts that wars of today have shifted away from conventional style warfare towards guerilla war (including the use of terrorism). By abandoning the Occupied Territories and building a wall around Israel's borders (like the wall going around the West Bank today), Martin Van Creveld states that this is the best way to deal with current and future threats to Israel's security. In addition, Van Creveld offers thought provoking ideas about the nature of Israel's security from the burgeoning private security industry to ideas as to whether strategic weapons (e.g. "nukes" - assuming that Israel has them) should be placed on mobile platforms like ships.
No doubt this has a strong impact on Israeli politics, for it is what Prime Minister Ariel Sharon has been doing before he succumbed to a stroke some time ago. Whether his successor, Olmert, can carry on with this strategy remains to be seen. Nevertheless it is a most amazing book that has left a big, lasting impact on Israeli and Middle East politics overall.
Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, by Martin van Creveld PDF
Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, by Martin van Creveld EPub
Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, by Martin van Creveld Doc
Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, by Martin van Creveld iBooks
Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, by Martin van Creveld rtf
Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, by Martin van Creveld Mobipocket
Defending Israel: A Controversial Plan Toward Peace, by Martin van Creveld Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar